On Following Jesus by Henri Nouwen - with Gabrielle Earnshaw / Transcript

Note: Can I Say This at Church is produced for audio listening. If able, I strongly encourage you to listen to the audio, which has inflection, emotion, sarcasm where applicable, and emphasis for points that may not come across well in written word. This transcript is generated using a combination of my ears and software, and may contain errors. Please check the episode for clarity before quoting in print.

Back to the episode


Intro

What is happening everybody, how are you doing? I hope your week is good. I hope this conversation finds you good. I have a couple quick requests for you. One of them is new. So yes, there's the obligatory support the show, check out patreon. Do the things rate and review the show on iTunes or pod bean or pod chaser or anything else with the word pod in it. Do that. I will say there were two reviews just a few weeks ago, one of them had like five or six people, four of which I don't think I've ever heard of that I have loved diving into their work, and I'm gonna try to get them onto the show.

Because the review requested that and I love new voices. I love new ideas and new thoughts. Let me know, email me all that goodness, but you know, rate, review, support the show, tell your friends, share the podcast, all the things. The show continues to grow and it's because of you that it does.

But here is my other request. So quickly approaching is Episode 100. And I'm going to try to do something different. I won't interview anybody. I want to talk a bit about the impact that doing this podcast over the last 100 episodes has had on me and my life and my faith and the way that I see, and chase, and fall more in love with God. But what I'd really like to do as well is answer just some of your questions as well. However you want to send those to me, I will correlate them but shoot me some questions and I know that if you have them because I get the emails, and I love responding to those. But I would love to do some of that in a more public forum. So send me your questions. If you don't want your name read, tell me and I'll make sure that I either change it or call everybody anonymous. But open request, send me what you want to know. I am looking forward to doing what I think will be the second solo episode. Besides a few brief updates, and the very, very first episode, I'm excited to do it, and I'm also terrified, but let's do it. Why not?

The topic today is “what does it mean to follow Jesus in an age that everybody's anxious?” Like, what does that look like? What is the return and the going look like? What does Jesus call us to be? Why does it matter? How do I not get anxious about it? How do I deal with trauma, like so much, so much here? And so I was able to sit down, electronically because the guest was in Canada, with Gabrielle Earnshaw, who is the editor of quite a bit of the life and work of Henry Nouwen, and if you don't know who in right now and as you just need to hit pause right now and Google that…the man has impacted so many lives, mine among them.

And so he has a book that is out, if it's not out today, it's out like tomorrow, called Following Jesus. It's a beautiful read. It's a simple read, but it is deeply profound. And those are my favorites, the ones that are written in a way that everyone can understand. And things bleed through and seep in, that you weren't expecting. I really hope that you get as much out of this as I did. And I would highly encourage you, I don't usually do this before we even get on the topic. Go out and get this book following Jesus is fantastic. It is it's it's been a blessing to read. So here we go. A Conversation with Gabrielle Earnshaw on some of the work of Henry Nouwen.

Seth

Gabrielle Earnshaw I am excited to be talking with you and like we talked about a moment ago, slightly nervous to be talking with you because normally the author in question is not posthumous and so that's always fun but thank you, either you or whomever at your publishers or the people that publish the book for sending me an advance copy.

I have loved digging in to Following Jesus from Henry Nouwen but we will get there. Can you tell me kind of a bit about you? What makes you tick and kind of how you got into this?

Gabrielle

Okay, sure. Well, I live in Toronto, Canada, and I, I guess began my work with Henry Nouwen as archivist, I was asked in the year 2000. So it's now 19 years ago, I was asked to start his archives, his papers. Some of his papers had been at Yale University where he taught. And then other papers of his were at L'Arche Daybreak, where he lived for the last 10 years of his life, which is close to Toronto. It's a community for people with intellectual disabilities that he was the pastor for; and I was called in to create an archives for him. And I worked on that for 16 years and it took me 10 years to work through his correspondence alone. He had 16,000 incoming letters that he kept. And then we also instigated a program to collect letters that he wrote to people that they would still have. And so we collected those letters. So that's the type of thing that I've been doing. I did an oral history project on him. So I've become a person who knows a lot about his archives. I know a lot about his family because I've actually was spent a sabbatical in Holland where he's from, and I lived in his former in his father's and mother's house, they're no longer alive. But his younger brother owned the house at the time. And my husband and I lived in it for three months and really, you know, immersed ourselves in Henry Nouwen in his home country.

Seth

What did you do before that? Because Well,

Gabrielle

before that,

Seth

yeah, and then

Gabrielle

Okay,

Seth

what the heck is an archivist? So I hear that and I think somebody's printing everything. Gabrielle

Sure.

Seth

How does that work?

Gabrielle

Okay, so in answer to your first question. I sort of had a classic middle class, childhood in Toronto. I wasn't raised in any religion, which might surprise people because now I am, you know, immersed in Christianity, but I was raised in a very secular household.

But what might be a little bit different than other people is, when I was younger, I started taking myself to church. And that sort of, I think, set me on my path really, I started going to United Church of Canada and the minister was very, a wonderful person and I loved playing the recorder and I love singing and and I guess the the church even though my family wasn't attending, it became a place that I really look forward to going to every Sunday.

And so church and religion generally what is a very, very meaningful and church, is a place where I feel like I belong. So that's an interesting aspect of me I think and my family still is very secular. And, and I attend the United Church now to this day.

And then your second question…what is an archivist? An archivist is somebody who cares for the records of either a person or an organization; like a government or a bank or something like that. I ended up working on papers related to individuals.

So papers can include even though we say papers or records we are referring to everything like photographs and video recordings and administrative files and computer files and, you know, correspondence and draft manuscripts and everything you can think of the person's life all of the records that a person needs to participate in life.

And so when Henry Nouwen and died he had kept almost all of his records. I like to say that he was he was his own best archivist. All I needed to do was just make sure that nothing nothing got lost or misplaced after he died because he he kept absolutely everything. He was very fastidious with his filing. And so my job as an archivist was to create finding guides or ways that scholars or other researchers could use the material, either for their own research for a PhD or a master's thesis, but it could also be for journalists or just regular people who were interested.

I had people who came in and tried to, who looked at letters for example on how he counseled people who got divorced, you know, that kind of thing. So the records are there for everyone to use. And my job for 16 years was to catalog them and make them available to people and make them find double.

Seth

And so you said that was your job? Is that not ongoing anymore. Is it complete, like we have all the things or you're I can't do this anymore?

Gabrielle 10:00

No, I just came to a crossroads in my work with that, with the archives, the archives is very much alive and, and well and people can go to use it at any time. It's at the University of St. Michael's college at UT, in Toronto. But I think what happened to me was I was asked to edit a book of Henry's letters. And, I did that it took me about a year to do and by the time I finished so I took some time off from the work as an archivist. And I guess I got hooked on that. And I've been doing editing books by or about Henry Nouwen since then, and that's been about three years that I've been doing that.

Seth

That book that you reference, is that the one that I'm holding? Is that the book Following Jesus? Is that a different book?

Gabrielle

No, no, it's actually called Love Henry. Letters on the Spiritual Life and it was published in 2016. It's a, I don't think I'm wrong to say, it's a very beautiful book, what I did is I found all the letters that I felt..we collected about 5000 letters; of those letters, I selected letters that I thought would speak most clearly to people's needs today.

So I try to really think about what it is that the 21st century Christian or the 21st century seeker needed to hear. And Henry was a very, very generous letter writer. He was a prolific letter writer, and he wrote to his good friends, as you might expect, but he also wrote extensively and beautifully to people who wrote to him with a question or a problem. So a lot of the letters read, like spiritual direction. So that's why they really, I feel like a person reading them today could feel as though he's writing to them.

Seth

Yeah.

Gabrielle

So that's that book. And then I edited a book of a devotional.

So I went through every, Henry wrote 39 books, and I went through each of them in chronological order, and selected the, what I felt were the gemstones in each of the books, which was quite difficult. I ended up with a 600 page document with that one.

laughter from both

And I had to whittle that down to of course 365 days, or 366 days so I that that book came out last year. And then now this is the latest one Following Jesus, which is quite different because following Jesus is based on talks that Henry did in 1985.

So my work as editor was to take something that was spoken over a six week period, one one night a week for six weeks in March of 1985. And, and and turn it into something that people could read without losing Henry's enthusiasm and the immediacy of what it would have been like to have been a person sitting in the pews.

He gave his talks in a church at Harvard. And so I tried to retain his voice as much as possible, but even that… the excited voice that he had some times when he wants to really connect with people, but also make it so that it's, you know, sort of, not repetitive, or, you know, make it more readable.

Seth

Yeah,

Gabrielle

so that was my task that I was given about a year ago now. And now it's the exciting moment when the book is going to be read by other people.

Seth

Again, I've very much enjoyed reading it. One of my favorite…I don't know if this was done, it had to have been done by someone that does work like what you do…

And to be honest before you'd said you were an archivist. Like, I didn't know that that was a job that exists. Although in hindsight, it must; it obviously…it makes sense that it does exist, but I just never, I'd never thought- it never occurred to me.

But one of my favorite books, I bought it at a used bookstore across from my work. And it is the second volume of a bunch of letters of CS Lewis.

Gabrielle

Ohhh

Seth

and I bought it, I thought it was going to be theological letters. And some of them are, but by some, I mean a minute amount. It is mostly letters to like professors and a conversation about the wars, and politics and economics. And that is just brilliant. Like, I'm reading it. I'm like, yeah, this isn't what I thought it would be. I was really hoping for some theology, but this is really good. And, I mean, it's just nice to see a candid side of people that are

Gabrielle

Yeah,

Seth

less edited. I really enjoy that.

Gabrielle

Yes, and that was the same goal for the letters book as well; was to sort of allow people into into Henry's life a little bit more and I organized them chronologically so that you could see his development and his even his transformation.

I think that it's for somebody who is writing about spiritual transformation, that the fact that he actually underwent one and that it's actually documentable. It's a gift actually. And I didn't know that it would, when I started out with that book, I did not know that I would end up with this portrait of a man transformed by his faith. And that and that, that is what you know, makes Henry Nouwen somebody who a lot of people can relate to because they're also struggling in their faith and in their following Jesus-to get to our book we're talking to tonight.

And he did as well and then he would write about it with with a lot of raw honesty, and a lot of people can can relate to it and then feel freer to struggle themselves in a way that is transformative.

Seth 16:00

Just from the opening missive and if it's all right, there's a part like right at the beginning that I want to talk a bit. Kind of that transformation, but just kind of maybe some of your thoughts as well. On the first chapter there, I believe the first chapter. Yeah, Chapter One is the invitation. And there's a part where there's just all these quotes of what Jesus doesn't say, which I've never really heard it put that way.

Gabrielle

Do you know what page?

Seth

17-second and a half paragraph?

Gabrielle

Okay. Oh, yeah. Right. Yeah.

Seth

So yeah, everyone says, you hear it every Sunday or many Sundays, Jesus says, Come and see, you know, come on with me, you know, leave your feet and put the Nets down. Let's go do this thing. But, Henry's here saying, you know, but here's what he doesn't say.

He doesn't say Come on, and I'll change you. He doesn't say become my disciples. Listen to me. He doesn't say to do what I tell you. No, he says, just come around, look around and get to know me.

Like that's the invitation get to know me. I'm curious in so you talk about Henry you know, transforming throughout these times.

Can you break that apart a bit, which is some of what you know of it of? Here's what we're getting at when we're inverting that question of, here's what everybody knows, Jesus said, but it's more important to talk about what he didn't say.

Gabrielle

Yeah. Well, that's, I mean, that's one of the beauties of this book. And that's why a lot of people felt it was a it was something that needed to happen and that's why they asked me to do it. And I think it's because he, I could have called this book and I in fact, I probably even put it forward as an idea like let's call this book Following Jesus: It's not what you think.

Because I think in a way Henry certainly did not have a confrontational style in the least he refers to Jesus is very Invitational I think of Henry is very Invitational, he has no desire to force anyone to believe anything he's saying he, in fact, the more you read of him, or and I've listened to a lot of his talks, he's often saying…

Listen to this with your heart. I know you're going to you know, you've been trained, especially as University people or even people who've gone to any kind of schooling, you've been trained to listen to this with your head. But listen to this with your heart and don't ask, Do I agree with this or disagree with this? But ask how does this relate to my own experience?

And Henry was really not interested in people listening to him so much as him providing space for them to listen to God. That was his whole…he had a personal transformation. But as far as I've been able to see, he started off with that. He started off a very young priest, even in this earliest works. In his earliest letters, he had that kind of…it was like I'm a witness. I'm telling you what I have experienced No, tell me what you've experienced. And I think if you've read some more of the book, you'll see that he he's often times telling the reader to, don't just take my word for it. Think about this for yourself, test this out in your own life. Listen, listen to what your own life is telling you. And then relate it back to what I'm saying and see if it rings any bells. Yeah.

I wanted to just just reflect on this. What Henry says that, you know, Jesus, when the very first his very first, sort of, in the in the first chapter, he's talking about, how is it that Jesus introduces himself to people he does it in a very gentle way. And he does it in a way that where the people that he is speaking to, in this case, it's John and Andrew, they ask the questions and he answers them in a very in a very…he has no expectations.

No, mandate, he's just saying come and see, are you interested in me? Come and see. And then he says dwell with me. And Henry focuses on this passage in the Bible because he wants to suggest that there is an Invitational quality to following Jesus. There is nothing about following Jesus that is mandatory or should feel constrictive in any way we follow.

Henri will go on to say

I we follow out of love, not out of fear. We don't follow Jesus to to know to be like him. We follow Jesus to follow our unique vocation.

We each have our own unique vocation Jesus had his unique vocation. And we have our unique vocation. And a word that comes to mind frequently for me around Henry Nouwen is freedom, there's a freedom in how he writes it's very Invitational, very open, it creates space, but he's also aiming for freedom. So freedom to be loving people.

One of the main trajectories of that, maybe that you also got out of the book is that there's this trajectory of how can I be a more loving person? What's constricting me, what's, what's holding me back. And then he goes even further, as you as you might know, he talks about loving our enemies.

He says, this is the one place that the New Testament is actually new. And I really loved that. This is where Jesus is saying, love your enemies. And I think that, obviously, this is the most challenging aspect of being a follower of Jesus; being a Christian is to really deeply absorb that, that I don't want to say commandment but that invitation, I guess, let's call it an invitation to love our enemies.

And I feel like this book is like a treatise on love, in fact, because he does talk about love, between people in marriages, in relationships in families, and then with our colleagues and he talks about sort of human love. And he calls it transactional. We have a transactional way of viewing love. Like we say, well, I'll love you, if you love me, you know, I'll give you this, if you give me that are the just sort of seems to be baked in to us.

We have that sort of in our DNA, but he's saying, but as followers of Jesus, we have to love out of God's love. And that how can we do that? We do that by knowing knowing in our deepest being that we are beloved by God, that we are the beloved sons and daughters of God. So I think that there's there's challenge in this book. But there's also I feel like he lays out a path that makes it easier to follow; somehow after reading it, the path of being a follower of Jesus.

Seth

And so, I've got it highlighted here, you just touched on it briefly there. When we talk about love and the gospel and loving your enemies. And I think you're right and you touch on it. I think it's in a prior chapter on scarcity, we're so afraid that for some reason, like there's like, somehow the economy at a cosmic with a K, Greek Kosmos,

Gabrielle

mmhmmm!!

Seth

is somehow we're going to run out of compassion, or love or race, or mercy.

Gabrielle

Yeah, yeah.

Seth

And that's only going to be filled with fear and rage and anger. But then you also, you know, here on page 63, it says, you know, the good news of the gospel is that God has no enemies. The Gospel tells us that God loves every human being the same way with the same intensive love. And I like that, like the economy of scarcity, like there is not an economy of scale. And I love talking about that because economics is like I literally work at a bank for a living. So economics, jam. And when that I'm like, Yes. And the transactional quid pro quo. Diana bass wrote a great book last year on gratitude about all the quid pro quo and transactional based stuff. Yeah, absolutely love that. I want to touch back on…

Gabrielle

can I just make one one comment on that, like, one thing that I love that relates to that is that he called it the logic of God. You know, and we are such rational, logical people. I mean, this is this is how we're, you know, this is how we're trained from, you know, going to kindergarten all the way up. We are trained to use our intellect to use our cognitive function and to, to be extremely logical and rational and Henri points out that actually God that there's no logic to God. It's complete logic and that's I again I find that very freeing because then you can start to see that all around you instead of looking for how things are you know falling into place and and you know things like well there should be a lack of food because we have you know, you know X Y Z but then you can start saying well actually where am I seeing abundance and in fact I'm and then you start looking for abundance when you when you hear that there is this logic to God you start looking for abundance and you see it all around you.

Seth

When I read those stories of abundance towards the beginning like you know there's there's too many bread there's too much fish there.

There's too many fishin the net there's just just go give it give it away the multitude. But I read it in for some reason, the back of my mind I read it in a playfulness, like not only is there's so many fish, and you're just missing the point, there's a silly amount of fish like, it's just ridiculous. Like, I know you don't believe me, but if you look down there, you can't even count them. Because there's just a silly amount of fish and want to dwell and I want to broach two parts together, because in my mind, I feel like they are so there's a part here where it says, gosh, where is it? I got it here it is,

like a child dwells in the house with her mother and father. Just dwell, play around sit there half hour, just sit there, just be present.

But that juxtaposes for me towards the tail in there, where we talk about being present. And then there's a part that says, you know,

we grow more intimate by constant leaving and returning.

And then he says, You know,

I want us to feel that for a moment because that's how we might come in touch with the mystery of spiritual life.

And so how did those two you think maybe interplay together of dwelling, but also leaving and going? Because they don't seem to make sense together but read separately they do. But I feel like they're so totally connected.

Gabrielle

Okay, well, I think first of all, in a way, you know, we have the subtitle of the book, it's finding our way home in an age of anxiety.

And I think home is a major theme of this book. What does home mean? And I think what we're talking about mostly here is our spiritual home. And and Henri is, I think, very emphatic that we begin to really trust that our home is in God and with God, and that we live our lives we do the leaving and the returning in the world, knowing that we are always within the home of God.

So there's a leaving and a returning, which is an important part of spiritual maturity and even just maturity through life. But I think in this way as followers of Jesus in the Christian context, it means to be home, even while you're on the road. Does that make sense? In fact, I think he even says that we that we can be home, even while we're on the road and what he means is that we are so deeply steeped in our identity as a child of God, that we can go and come and we can suffer and we can struggle, but at all times we are in the home and in the embrace and in the safety of God.

28:55

The other thing I think he means about dwelling in it's really important is that none of this can happen without spiritual disciplines. We cannot retain that identification as children of God without constant prayer, without a constant conversation with God. So when he's talking about dwelling he in sometimes he's talking about it in a more of a in that more metaphysical sense, but sometimes he's actually just talking about take 15 minutes out of your day and dwell, sit still, sit in silence, be in solitude, and sit with God be with God.

And in those cases, you don't even have a conversation with God at that point. This is this is really where you're sitting in the silence. I like to think of it like I'm crawling into the lap of God and that I am sitting there. And you know, like a child with a parent. You don't need to say anything at that point, right. There's no need to fill the space with with language with words, and I think that for Henri Nouwen it's of primal importance to have time in our day that is completely set aside for creating space for God.

That is a very constant theme in all of his books and all of his writing and all of his talks. Because it was very important for him. He was a really restless person, he was restless, he couldn't even, like if you met him, you could see that he had a kind of nervous energy.

I never met him. But I've heard this from many, many people. So he, you know, any images of him being very, you know, sort of calm and, you know, in a meditative state at all times is completely, not a good image of him. He ran around a lot. He left a lot. He did a lot of leaving. He was in a huge search for how to follow Jesus and this question of the discernment of how do I follow Jesus?

Where do I follow Jesus was his main question. And this led to him being quite restless and moving around a lot. And then consequently also being very lonely and having bouts of depression, he really did struggle a lot, but a lot of his wisdom comes from that struggle.

And I think a lot of his authenticity and the reason why I can trust him as a reliable guide, as a trustworthy guide, for my own spiritual life, is because he was struggling with all of these things. He had something in his core that he was always listening to the voice of God, always in conversation with Jesus, always in prayer.

And so he was a Catholic priests of course, he was, this was his vocation, this was his formation. But, still, I think even people like me, can identify with him.

Seth 32:00

You had a metaphor there of a child crawling up into my lap, which I have two young girls any young son. And that's what literally that happened tonight. My daughter and it's probably inappropriate, but whatever. Like I go to her bedroom, she just taken a bath. She's four. And she's playing a game like, I'm not gonna put on my underwear, you're gonna put on my underwear. And this just keeps collapsing in me.

And she's like, we're going to do lotion. I'm like, No, you're going to put on your underwear. Because I'm a little bit uncomfortable at the moment. I'm going to need you to put on something little baby girl, but then she just cuddles. And I love it and I love it. But, I know, and I get emails and messages that that is not the case like some people are rejected. And that is hard to envision that type of love. So what do you think, because Henri dealt with that so for those that are reading this are dealing with other texts, like how would you respond to this rejection?

Sin is real and that trauma is real, and here's how we can pivot on that to something way more beautiful.

Gabrielle

You're absolutely right. Self-rejection was Henri’s, for whatever reason, he dealt with that his whole life because in fact he wasn't rejected by his parents. He had loving, stable parents, they tell the story that from a very young age he would relentlessly ask the question, do you love me? Do you love me? Do you love me? And no answer was good enough for him. And this actually plagued him his entire life. I don't think he actually ever had that go away. But I think when I talk about his transformation, it's that he was able to live with that struggle and love in spite of it, and be free in spite of it. And I think it's really important. I don't think that for Henri at least and possibly for us as well; It's not necessary to be completely fixed, right?

We don't need to be completely healed. We don't need this, we can live with our suffering, we can live with our struggles, and still have lives of freedom and integrity and be fully loving people and be loved.

And I think that is what he would say to that m. But I know that he would, if he heard someone speak about about terrible rejection in the form of abuse or that manner of rejection, I think he would be in tears with you. And I think that he would cry with you. And I think that the compassion that he would feel for you or for anyone who is going through that…that would be coming from his own wound. His own wound that he was somehow able at a certain point in his life to bind up. It didn't go away, but he was able to bind it up. And from that wound, he was able to be compassionate to other people. And I think that a life of compassion is a life worth living. And I think a lot of people are asking, you know, what is the meaning of life? What's the point of all of this? And at a certain point in the book, you might remember Henri says, you know,

the answer is, if we follow Jesus. Now I know why I'm living like there's a, there's a kind of, it can totally reshape our lives following Jesus.

There's many components to it, but one of them is becoming a very compassionate person is being able to suffer with other people and to and to not run away from it. And to stand tall in it and in our own suffering. And I think that that's what he's talking about when one of his chapters is called The Cost.

You know, we have to hold our own crosses. And we have to bear our own crosses. But I think that there is an almost a beauty in that if you know you were saying how can we see it in a more beautiful light, but I also don't want to say that this is easy, and I don't think Henri Nouwen would say it's easy at all.

I think it's a lifelong journey to it. And, as I say, Henri Nouwen, you know, he died at 64 of a heart attack suddenly. But he was still struggling. If you read his last journal, he was still struggling with all of this…everything you could read in his first journals, but he was living it in a different way. And that's where possibly the hope is: that we can live our struggles in a different way, we can live our suffering in a different way.

We don't need to lash out at people because we're suffering. We can be more compassionate with people because we're suffering.

Seth

Yeah.

Gabrielle

I think that might be how he would answer it.

Seth

So we're following Jesus. And I don't even remember what page it was because I didn't highlight it. But there was a part in there recently about Jesus is giving people new names. And so when I think about me following Jesus, like, it's really one of the thoughts that I had was, you know, so what is my new name?

If I'm following Jesus, and I'm trying to be authentic, what is that? And I don't have an answer to that. And I don't really need to have an answer to that today. I do care. But I think that it's a great call to action of what what am I being called to? And what does that look like? What does that name, that beloved name, what does that look like?

One of my favorite pages pages of the entire book, Gabrielle is page 55. Where there is a conversation on the first love.

Gabrielle

Yeah,

Seth

I literally just want to frame the whole page.

Like, you know, it's I've loved you before you could love anyone. This is so beautiful. So, so beautiful.

Gabrielle

I love

the original Love is the original blessing. Long before we talk about Original Sin or original rejection, we should be speaking of God's original love.

And I think that is so true because we focus so much on sin and how we have to constantly be making up for this sin in some manner. And Henri is saying, let's put our gaze on something else. Henri does that a lot?

He'll say, “yes, of course, we could put our focus on there. But actually, let's shift our focus and put it on something else”. And this in this case, he saying, Let's gaze on this. The original love, God loved us with a…. God loves us, not “loved” us…loves us with the first love.

And when I was talking about love before I was talking about human love as transactional and he calls that the second love. And so the first love is to love as God loves us.

We can only do that when we feel in our very bones, that we are God's beloved children, and that God loved us before we could love anyone or before we could receive love from anyone.

Yeah, Henri Nouwen does a beautiful job. I think of this book, as a portrait of God in a sense too, and it's a portrait of God that some people might not recognize because God is so gentle, is so affirming and welcoming. And, as he says, he doesn't actually refer to God as male or female, but he says, God is home.

God is our refuge. God is our dwelling place. And if we could really feel that, I think life would change for us.

Seth

Yeah, I agree. I want to pivot if you're comfortable. So you talked at the very beginning about your family upbringing and then just kind of how your…. I assume Christian, I can't remember if you say Christian or not, I have to go back in and relisten. So how has diving into all of this stuff on Nouwen, not just this book, but so many things? How has that changed the way that you do faith? And I don't want to say religion because religion is not a big enough word, at least for the God that I worship. So how has all of this changed you?

Gabrielle

Wow. Changed me?

Well, obviously, I was already primed for some sort of, I think I was asking from a very early age, what does this all mean? You know, why are we here? Who am I? Those types of questions, I think, and I was in a house that wasn't asking those questions. I came from a loving house, but people weren't asking my family weren't asking those deeper questions. I experienced a lot of death in my life. My father died when I was two and my best friend died when I was 16.

I have experienced a lot of death in my life and so I think I've been these these types of questions have had a lot of urgency for me and I have always been a seeker looking for answers. So I've explored all the different religions I've read a lot of different spiritual writers and then by grace, I was chosen to be Henry Nouwen’s archivist, but not because I knew anything about Henri Nouwen; because I didn't.

I had never heard of him. But because I was the right person for the job from a professional standpoint. And so when I accepted that position, and believe it or not, it was a six month contract it was really not… it didn't look so great on you know, at first it was just going to be a six month contract, I would come in, or catalog the papers and then then leave.

But somehow I think that this was just the beginning for me.

Because then I was able to, it's like I became an apprentice of Henry Nouwen.

And then my son died when he was four and a half. And that's this is now going on to 10 years ago. And my son died of acute myeloid leukemia was a it was….it was every, you know, every bit as traumatic and catastrophic as you can imagine. And that's really when my, all of that reading all of that digesting of Henry Nouwen really helped me survive it. It was like everything I had read was now coming in, I was now living. And I had to make sense of my son's illness and then consequent death.

His his writing on grieving on how to live with that level of suffering. I feel like I couldn't have lived that experience the way I did without him. So it's quite profound actually is, the impact of him on my life. But it's not just that it's also about how I orient myself. You know, what's important to me.

Is it isn't important to earn a lot of money? Is it important to have a lot of prestige? Is it important that I, you know, look successful in the world's eyes?

I think my son's death really changed my worldview as well. But Henri Nouwen’s questioning of that has also had an impact on my life. So the decisions I make about how I'm going to spend my time have been impacted by him. And I think also that I have a spiritual practice that I believe in, you know, he writes about it with such eloquence that I believe it, and I have implemented it, and I live that.

It's hard to actually articulate how profound the impact of him on my life has been and, and the kind of the mystery of it. Because, as I say, I wasn't raised in a religious household. I don't have a theology degree. I, you know, I go to a very progressive United Church.

But here we are. I'm the person who is now quite familiar with Henri Nouwen.

Seth

Thank you for sharing that. I know, I didn't send you questions ahead of time. And so that probably caught you off guard, but thank you. That's, yes. So children that passed away from cancer or so in my family. My wife takes care of a lot of children with cancer. That's her specialty.

Gabrielle

Oh, wow.

Seth 45:00

pediatric oncology. hematology, infusion.

Gabrielle

Yeah, so those are special people.

Seth

I don't know how her and those others, I don't know how they do it. I don't know any part of the body that makes that happen. I don't possess it. I can't do it. I'm glad someone can.

But anyway, yeah, they leave me entirely speechless. But thank you for sharing that.

Gabrielle

Sure. I could say to that, that Henri Nouwen would say as you've read in the book that every person has their own unique vocation. And so to follow Jesus doesn't mean that we you know, imitate them like I mentioned earlier on. It means that we find our own vocation. And it might mean that you know, some people are meant for a quiet contemplative life some people you know, they express their love of God by doing social justice work. Some people express their love of God and their discipleship to Jesus by being a really good Dad, you know.

So every person who is a follower of Jesus is unique. And he, you know, he calls us all as being a mosaic and all together we, we become the face of God. So if you put all of us, individuals, every human being on the planet doing the, you know, following their, their vocation, their call, listening to God, and following their call, each of us becomes the face of God, but none of us can do it alone. And we need lots of people helping children with cancer, but we also need a lot of people doing other things. And, I think Henri would be quite impassioned about that is that there's no One way of following Jesus.

Seth

Where do people get the book? So it's out when is it September 17? Something like that. Right?.

Yeah, it's it's everywhere I assume correct everywhere? This probably is the book I've read most often this year since I've gotten it it's easy to read, it's not long, it's easy.

And it is oddly addictive.I just want to come back to it; it's written in a way that I like it but where can people go to learn more about work like this? Like, is there a place that I can listen to the talks that this book comes from? Is that a thing that exists? Or do I have to come to Canada to do so?

Gabrielle

Okay, so there is a Henri Nouwen society and and that's easy to find with Google. You just key and Henry Nouwen society and that will come up and it's kind of like the hub of all things Henri Nouwen, and it will list all of his books and you know, some information about more generally, and upcoming events, that kind of thing. If a person wants to really delve into into archival material, they can go to the Henri Nouwen archives at the University of St. Michael's college. And they don't have to go there physically, they can work with the archivists. They're electronically some, the talks are actually available through the archives. So you could listen to them online through the archives. They're not freely available, you have to go through them, but they are available.

Seth

Nice. I'm gonna make that happen. That's the person I am I like to rip these things apart. So I'm, yeah, I'm making that happen. So. Okay, yeah, I think I happen to know a person that knows who the new archivist is. And so I may collect it,

Gabrielle

Oh yeah?

Seth

I think it's you, but I might be wrong may get the best contact for that. Anyway.

Gabrielle

(laughter)

Seth

Thank you so much for coming on. I really appreciate it.

Gabrielle

I've enjoyed being invited and you taking the chance and inviting the editor of a posthumous work. That was a big risk, and I hope it was worth it.

Seth

I enjoyed it very much so. So thank you so much.

Outro  49:12

So when I think about this work put together by Gabrielle from some of the lectures of Henry Nouwen, you know, from the 80s it's amazing how much of it is relevant now as it was then. And I find so much graciousness, and that the fact that the words and lessons that we can learn from Christ supersede every single time and place and dimension of reality that we hold true. There's something about the way that we are called the way that there's purpose, the way that fear and hope are intertwined. You were blessed. You were wholly loved. You've always been accepted.

Talk with you next week.

The Church of Us vs. Them with David E. Fitch / Transcript

Note: Can I Say This at Church is produced for audio listening. If able, I strongly encourage you to listen to the audio, which has inflection, emotion, sarcasm where applicable, and emphasis for points that may not come across well in written word. This transcript is generated using a combination of my ears and software, and may contain errors. Please check the episode for clarity before quoting in print.

Back to the episode


Intro

Hey, friends, welcome back. It's another week, we did it. I usually steer away from politics and any conversation like that, because it is so charged. And we're already talking about faith, I would rather not talk about two charged topics, but the guest at hand that you will hear in a moment, wrote a book that just intersects it too beautifully. And I think for those listening, I'm going to go ahead, and you don't know what day this is. But, you know, tomorrow will be September 5, and I'm gonna go ahead and send out David's book, to the level of Patreon supporters that get books, I think this book is fantastic. And I can't wait for you all to get it. And so if you are not a Patreon supporter, there's some big things happening there, click the button and do it appreciate every single…every, every, every single one of you there the adequate words, to express how true that is, this show continues to grow at a pace that blows my mind. And without y'all that's just not, it's just not a thing that could happen. You know, another thing that you could do, if you can't do that, because I know not everybody can is you could just click the button, you know, an in iTunes, your podcast app of choice. And you could just rate the show, type in a little comment there and say, you know, Seth is awful at this, or I really enjoyed this. Or you can say whatever you want. Just say something, I read those. And some of them I love, some of them made me laugh. Others I won’t to talk about. So one of my favorite songs, I listened to it frequently, quite frequently, actually, is from Gungor, and it's called us for them. And I love that play on words. And there is a lyric in there towards the end, you know, that says, you know,

prepare the way of the Lord wielding mercy like a sword. You know, every mountain topple be made low, he holds the earth like dust and his judgment, his love. His judgment is love.

And then it says

we will not fight their wars, we will not fall in line because if it's us, for them, it's us for them. We reject the binary either or like it's just us for them.

And so David's book is titled on the church of us versus them. And I think that that is so often the rhetoric that permeates every single conversation, be it religious or non religious, it's just always my side versus your side, somebody must lose. There's no discernment, there's no patience. There's just finger pointing. And I am as guilty as the next person.

I love this conversation. I love this book. I'm sending it to some of you. And if you're not on that list, get the book. It is very It is very good. And so here we go. No more belaboring the point. Here is the conversation that I have with David E. Fitch about freedom from a faith that feeds on making enemies.

Seth

David E. Fitch and I'm partial to the “E” also have any mines Edward I don't know what yours is. But Welcome to the show. Man. I'm excited. You're here.

David

Good to be here. And I won't tell you what my e is because I don't want anyone to make fun of me on the airwaves…but it’s Elmer

Seth

That's but you said you. Are you making that up? Or that's the real name?

David

No, that is my real middle name. And it's a sacred name in our family. It links back to my grandfather.

Seth

Yeah, I'm I am similar with mine

David

It's got huge lineage in my family.

Seth

I'm with you. Both of my names are grandparents further up down the line. So I'm with you and we've done the same thing with my son like he's in his middle name is named after grandfather and you know, etc. So yeah, no, I definitely. Why would I make fun of your name? Like you had any choice? And but Oh, that would do that.

David

I'm not saying it'll be you. But it would get back to me somehow.

No, I named my son, Elmer. Elmer Max Fitch. And my wife said, well, we'll go with the Elmer but nobody can actually call him Elmer. The only person that can know about Elmer is you and me. And so that's kind of the way you know, his first name is Elmer. But nobody calls him Elmer. And want anybody to know, his first name is Elmer, can you imagine this?

Seth

Well, he will now

David

Hopefully this won’t get back to him

Seth

My favorite conversations are the ones that I laugh a lot. And we're already doing that. So we're well on our way to making this a good one. What would you want people to know about you, David? Like, what is kind of your story? Like what makes you…you?

David

Well, I know most people know me, because I'm a theologian, and I've written books. But the real story is, I was a struggling guy coming out of seminary that got a job as a stockbroker. Rose to the heights of Wall Street, you know with some well off people, I did, okay, in other words, in like, six years, and then I had I tell people.

I got saved, saved for real the second time. And that's when I began a journey of studying for a PhD and running a business and leading a church and trying to sort out life in the big city, if I can put that way. And so I didn't come at being an academic by choosing to be an academic. I actually went through all kinds of stuff, searching, struggling, going through a PhD, leaving the church, writing a book. And then I was asked to take an academic position. I think I want people to know, I'm a pastor, and I've gone through…I've gone through stuff, that non righteous people that grew up living a perfect life have gone through. Does that make sense?

Seth

Yeah, although, I mean, I can half relate to that being in finance. I didn't know you were in the financial world. I like that. Because I often tell people if I could actually make the amount of money that I need to make, and do this full time. And so if you're listening, somebody make that happen. I would I get so much fulfillment out of doing this, I read so many new ideas. And so I am envious, that you did it, you know that you've done it. Not that I don't like banking? I do like it. But I love this, if that makes sense…

David 8:04

Well, I wouldn't say I've done it, I'm, you know, Stanley Hauerwas starts off the first line of his autobiography, by saying “I did not intend to be Stanley Hauerwas”.

I did not intend, really, for my life to develop the way it did. It was just like submitting faithfully to what God had for me. And if I had to do it all over again, I probably would have done it differently. But actually, God works in through all things to achieve and accomplish His purposes. So that's the way it turned out. And probably who knows if you stay faithful day in day out to your job and this work? Who knows? guys can take you. That's a message for anybody, not just this old guy talking on a podcast.

Seth

But yeah, who does know? I mean, if you'd asked me five years ago, if I would be sitting right here at this moment, I would have been like, Yeah, probably not. Nobody cares what this idiot has to say. And I would still think that that's probably true. But I think people care for a genuine conversations, which leads me to what you've written. So the book that you have most recently written, I think came out in what is it July? Is that when it came out?

David

Yeah.

Seth

And so I apologize. I think I've had it since then. And I’ve just been so…because July, the summer months for me, I’ve got three small kids that are consuming, like consuming is not the applicable adjective... like it just sucks the life out of everything. But it's fun. They're all under the age of 10. And it is consuming.

David

Wow.

Seth

So I read your book a while back, and then I refreshed on it a little bit before talking to you today. And I absolutely liked this book. And so when you say the church of us versus them, I wanted to start with that, like, who is us? Who is them?

David

Yeah, well, it starts with the church, it just starts with a general description of churches, United States of America, and how we started defining ourselves; self understanding who we are by who we're not. And so church has kind of develop this mentality, this competitive mentality, this us versus them mentality, even within the church. So, you know, John MacArthur might define him, and who he is over against the charismatics, or over against the social justice people, etc, etc. And that kind of mentality kind of spreads the progressives against the conservatives, the arming LGBTQ against the non affirming, and we have all these us versus them, definitions of who we are as Christians, but it doesn't stop there, it actually becomes the DNA of how we relate to the world.

And so we can't get we define ourselves over against this person or that person. It's kind of like a disease. It's kind of like an idiological way of being that is infested how we gather as a people. And my argument or my plea, in the church of us versus them is, no, this is not who and who Jesus is, this is not the people of God in Christ. This is not who were called to be. Let's get out of this ideological existence. So we can be the people of God for the world, and for his mission in the world.

Seth

Well, I mean, getting John MacArthur, he keeps switching to them, because he just gets mad at say, Well, I'm not that old, I'm almost I'm an upper mid 30s, there we go. Um, but in my just limited history, like, he just yells at somebody different every couple years, he finds a new them, which seems like a lot of energy wasted, like, you should really just target somebody. And if you're going to act that way, you know, beat them into submission, I guess, if that's the mindset, but he seems to jump around from who is the them, which seems just like a lot of wasted energy.

David

And people are going to accuse me of like, defining myself over against John MacArthur. And there's always those feeling, he, you know, double negative things that happen, we can't get out of the spiral. But just looking at Dr. MacArthur and what goes on, it kind of illustrates the principle of the way ideology works. If you have to define yourself and who you are, and rally a crowd, by gathering them against an object or an enemy, I described this in, I think, the first couple of chapters of the book, then once that runs out, you've got to find a new enemy, because that energy doesn't have anything substantive out of which to live life, and it will run out, the enemy will kind of have a shelf life, and then you'll have to invent a whole new enemy to keep the machine going.

And you know, we have a president in office right now, who basically lives this way every day. But it's very signifying as to kind of the bad habits we've gotten into, as far as the church and its formation as a people in the world.

Seth 13:17

So I usually intentionally do not talk politics, but I don't see a way to talk about this conversation, without government and politics like forefront. And so I just want to, I just wanna get a few things out of the way, I'm not a fan of the President. And those that know me know that. And so anything I say, to talk badly about our government is really from a heart of, I really wish that it would work, because I live here, and I needed to work. And my kids live here. And I need it to work. And so does everybody listening, and anyone that you share it with?

One of the things that annoys me and I, I argue all the time, David, about how we are not a Christian nation, how we've never been one. And it's, I find myself when I do that, though, I oftentimes feel like I'm creating a new us versus them. And it's not progressive versus that's not what I'm trying to say. I feel like it's those that know, history and those that don't. So how would you recommend someone have a conversation of an us versus them specifically, when it comes to like politics, as we're entering into the primary season? You know, in at recording, you know, the senator, what is it Gillibrand, I think that's who it is, you just dropped out of the race. And so that will continue to go. And as minds coalesce, the US is and then dems are going to get bigger, be that the church? Or be that the party of choice? So how do you enter into a conversation with someone, and even find a level playing field to begin a conversation in actual authentic by purpose,

David

What ideology does is, it creates a cause, and creates promises around that cause that are impossible to be fulfilled. And then it aligns, it kind of builds your identity around being against this enemy in this fraud. And what happens is you never…it takes you out of the actual discerning process of any real issue on the ground. This is what is so damaging about ideology, we extract beliefs or discernment’s out of their context out of actual discipleship, people's lives, and we turn them into a banner, I call it a banner, and then rally people using the banner against an enemy. And we never get to actually discerning anything, we do this in sexuality, right? We are either affirming or not affirming. And we go into these big culture wars, and rallying people to become so emotional, our identity gets so tied into it, we actually never get to actually talking to anybody was gauging all, as far as I know, engaged in sexuality issues of multiple complexities. But we never actually talked about or get to discerning these in these places of safety, under the redeeming work of the Holy Spirit, through Jesus Christ.

No, we never get to that we just stay above it all in these arguments for against now, this is what happens with politics. We create this imaginary christian nation as a cause to get behind. But nobody really believes forget all this legislation put it in, and all these supreme court justices putting it all of a sudden, we're going to have a nation that looks more Christian, actually, that kind of I've shown the book how that works against the idea of more Christian.

So what we do is we just get the strategy and I want to say no, let's actually work on the ground locally, on the issues that are so important politically, that we have to work out, you know, whether it be taxes, whether it be legislation for how we take care of our health care problems, or whatever it might be, let's start working it on the ground in groups of people. You know, that's what the word ecclesia, the Greek word, that Paul the Apostle used for church that came off the set to agent that referred to the people of Israel, but actually it was, it was actually a word that meant the political organizing locally, of every Greek, little state or city or village or town. And what Paul was saying is the church does the work of organizing people for God's kingdom in Christ, even though those people don't know they're under his rule yet. We're going to discern it here first. And then we're going to proclaim the good news to other people. And I just, I don't know if that was too long, and explanation, but I've what I'm really trying to say is let's start local. And let's stay on the ground and discern these issues locally. Whether it be Who should I vote for, whether it be how do we deal with taxes? Whether it be how do we deal with the injustices of racism in this town, or whatever it might be? Let's let's deal with it locally. And then let's work out solutions together as a people got then let's take him to the town hall village meeting. And let's take him to the state. You know, Canada's national health care system started in the in a small city in Saskatchewan, Canada, under the leadership of a Baptist pastor named Tommy Douglas. And the revolution began, it didn't start in Ottawa, House of Parliament started in a little town with a guy named Tommy Douglas.

Seth

Yeah, I remember I forget what book it was one of the first time I talked to a Benjamin Corey, I was reading a lot about, you know, back in like, you know, 17 1800s, like some of the church did some beautiful work, because they weren't really attached at the hip to making enemies or naming enemies, just actually maybe loving people, caring for people. And they did a lot. They start libraries start schools start churches start, you know, the Red Cross start Salvation Army. And I didn't know that about Canada. But that was back when the church, I think acted like one as opposed to a social club with money influence.

David

Yes, I think I give the example of how the civil rights movement didn't happen through Lyndon Baines Johnson and the administration in the White House, it happened. If you read Charles Marshes book, Beloved Community, all the history is kind of sketched out of the Jim Crow South and Nonviolent Coordinating Committee started to happen locally in various colleges, campuses, towns, villages, what they really were were prayer meetings, where people white and black, gathered together around tables, and started praying and upsetting the Jim Crow South. And from that came the civil rights movement.

We must understand, let's go local. So I'm saying, Let's because if we just get caught up in these ideological struggles about what does it mean to be a Christian nation, which really we don't, it really doesn't mean anything. We don't really know what it means. Like, what would it mean, for the United States to be a Christian nation? Can somebody please don't me that? I don't think we know. And I don't think it's possible to even you know, have a so called Christian nation at this point in time. No, what we need to do is go local, and spread the gospel, the justice of Jesus Christ, and every nook and cranny where we where we live and let God take care of how he's going to reign the world.

Seth

I agree, because I don't think we have a Christian nation because most Christians don't agree on simple things like say, the Bible, or so until there's that. I don't see how you could have a Christian nation, because that's, that's why we have all these different. Well, one of the reasons we have all these different denominations. One more thing on Christian nation, I've heard you either speak, or maybe I read it. But I've read a lot lately. But I've heard you talk about, you know, the pre and post World War Two, Germany and how it was the preeminent Christian nation, if there ever there was one, you've got all these Lutheran ministers, and kind of how that morphed into what it became. And a lot of that I remember when I when I saw it, I was like, this is I didn't have any of that context. I wonder if you could go into a bit of that here. Because I feel like I'm probably not the only one. Because I know in the school systems I went to we don't really talk about any things that aren't America. And so it's hard to make those correlations.

David

Yeah. Well, you know, the fact the matter was Germany, by legislation was Christian nation. Well, third Catholic, two thirds Lutheran, but it was all into the German church structure. We all pay taxes. So anyways, the real question, I mean, I'm still studying it to this day, I was happy to be in Berlin last summer stunned by just the history that that country is living and grieving over and repenting of, and how it all happened. But you know, all you have to do is study, Dietrich Bonhoeffer in the end, the German church movement and the Barman Declaration, to see how by the time the church woke up, it was too late. And it was in the church, the German church, and you know, I Dietrich Bonhoeffer, one of the things was, like, I don't know how famous this is, but when I read it, it became famous to me said the reason why seven thousand Lutheran pastors that have for one reason and can summarize their pensions.

So when money and power and everything gets loaded up into the structure, we end up succumbing. And I think the same power is going on today, with so many white evangelicals in the south. aligning themselves with a very non Christian, almost disgusting administration is mind boggling how the ideologies gotten ahold of us. So I think we need to study how and when things happened in Germany, there's a lot of people who poo poo that idea, oh, this is not Germany. But yet there are things to learn from what happened there. And how we became, I have this, these two lectures I'm I'm writing right now, in the process to deliver in California in February, where I say the problem isn't that we're on the wrong side of history. The problem is that we're on the wrong side of power. You know, the argument is get on the right side of history, and get ahead of things. Actually, every time we've been on the wrong side of power, things have gone very wrong. God works among the poor, the hurting, the broken, the marginalized, because his power doesn't operate the way the world's power does. And he changes things where his power spaces may open for. So anyways, all these things we can study through the German church problem. And you know, I'd start with Reggie Williams. Bonhoeffer’s Black Jesus. Love that book, in terms of understanding how we can get so sucked up into white nationalism. And we're just not seeing this is not the gospel. This is not Jesus.

Seth

I don't know anything about that book. But I'm going to fix that today. So you talked, you talked there. And there's a reason I asked that question. I hope that you go there. And so that's why you're a person rational, and I am not. So you talked about, you know, the way that you know, we have a love affair with power, and evangelicalism. And I struggle with that word, I struggle to call myself an evangelical because it means so many other things that have nothing to do with the gospel. But that's a slightly different topic. But you’ve got a section in a chapter on let's make America Christian again, that's titled and the reason it's caught me as I went to Liberty, and so I'm very attuned to Jerry Falwell and the Moral Majority. And so you say Jerry Falwell, or Jim Wallace, what's the difference? So what is the difference for those that haven't read the book like what he's saying there?

David

I'm an Anabaptist most people know I'm a NEO Anabaptist. I have learned from Stanley Hauerwas and many other Neo Anabaptists. It just, I tell people, Stanley Hauerwas, you know, was the means by which I became a Christian again, he got me into understanding the Bible. One of the one of the things anabaptism is we realize that God's power in in through Jesus Christ, and I do believe its power. But it is just so different. Usurping force, violent power of the world, and by violence, I just don't mean physical violence, or shooting somebody with a gun. Although that is a very visceral manifestation of the same dynamic. I mean, all forms of force all forms of coercion, all forms of me over you getting you to do something that I want you to do in the name of an agenda or some purpose that I have decided or become part of.

So anyways, the whole point here is, is that there's two kinds of power. Another distinction in theological world is preservatory power. Luther call that the left hand of the government and the right hand is redemptive power. What I'm trying to say here is, is that we need to understand that Jim Wallace, who was an Anabaptist, suddenly started writing books like God's Politics, and we've got to do things through the government. And yet he had this he had a Biblically, I think he called it the Isaiah platform. And that book, and he's got a very Biblically are well argued, biblical ethic that he wants the government to enforce. Very similar to Jerry Falwell, of course, and the Moral Majority, although both have they both had very different senses of what what what that ethic and the emphasis within that should be, they both took the same means, which is let's get the government to do the bidding of God.

And what I want to say is, government can do some things. But it's very limited. So go ahead and vote and go ahead and work for government. But it's going to be very limited, the redemptive work of what God wants to do in our culture can come only in in through the church through the power, and the presence of God through Jesus Christ. That may sound very individualistic, because that's the way evangelicals have already said it. I believe it's very social. I think God wants to work in in through the neighborhoods, and the places of worldly power, for his purposes, through his presence, and to the way he works in the world. Does that make sense? Can you clarify for me everything I just said?

Seth

(Laughter) just read the book. There we go.

David

laughter……

That's why I see Jim Wallace and Jerry Falwell as two sides of the same coin.

Seth

Yeah.

David

Employing worldly power to accomplish their biblical agendas, even though their Biblical agendas are quite different.

Seth

I don't think there's a way to read the Bible. I think it's really hard to read the Bible and not read looking for the God that you're trying to find. And I don't know that I'm saying that well, and but then you take that as ammunition. And so I want to backtrack back to the beginning of the book, you talk about people using the Bible is a blunt instrument. And that phrasing is used often. And so I'd like to turn the question a bit, how would you invite us You said, you know, you're a pastor. And I mean, obviously, you're training pastors while you're an academic. And so in your experience, how would you train pastors to instead of using the Bible as a blunt instrument, to use it as a precise one? Because I think there is a purpose for how Scripture can sometimes cut down what doesn't need to be there. So how would we instead frame using Scripture and using Scripture is a bad way to say that, you know, letting Scripture use us as a precise instrument, as opposed to just a God hates gays? God only likes Republicans, you know, or whatever the blunt, whatever the blunt thing is,

David

Yeah, well, we have to deconstruct.

I'm going to use a couple of big words here.

Seth

Perfect.

David

I'm going to deconstruct epistemology, the way we know something. We have said, The Bible is inerrant, every word is God breathed. perspicuous is a word the reformers have used, it is eminently clear, all I have to do is my homework, and I get to the right, meaning. But we individualized that; the fact of the matter is that worked in Christendom, Euro-Christendom where there was already a consensus on what all the texts means.

Now go to your average church meeting or go to a pick a commentary off your library wall, and you'll find four or five meanings for every text, for every verse. Well, how do we deal with that? You know, so the first thing I think, when we, when we meet over an issue, it's a communal work of God, by His Holy Spirit; Acts chapter 15 I think it is, you know, they got together, they asked, what does this mean, they will search the Scriptures. They said, We are seeing the Holy Spirit at work in Gentile believers. What does this mean? And then what are the demands, and then they say it See, it is good, thenI believe James wrote that, that note, it seems good to us and the Holy Spirit to do A, B and C. You know, that's the process of how we gather together to interpret Scripture on things that we don't agree on.

And so when we had a couple of people, wonderful people disagree with our church, and how we were affirming women in ministry, we all got to get there. All those who were committed to this issue. Some were even offended that we would open up the discussion again, of women ministry. But we first deconstructed what Scripture is, we all bring agendas here. We're submitting them to the work of the Holy Spirit, then we're going to look at verses and submit one to another and listen carefully and we're going to pray. And we're going to open space for God to speak. And we're going to hear all side. And we'll listen to the teachers. But we're also listening to pastors and the evangelists and the other gifted people in our midst.

And you know, after like seven weeks of going through the texts, and listening to one another, and we all came to some conclusions, we wrote some conclusions on the big whiteboard, or what we call it that we had, we didn't have everybody agree, like we take a one to five assessment. Where you? 1: Satan's working this affirmation that cannot agree…. 5: I agree wholeheartedly, 4: I have some reservations…but I could follow this.

We had no threes twos or ones, we had all fives and three fours, but even the ones who couldn't completely agree said, I can trust what the Holy Spirit is doing in this church, where he's leading us through the teaching, and submitting to Scripture on this issue. So everybody, everybody was met, in one way or another and came to a coalescence as to where God was taking us in relation to this issue. I wish we could do that kind of thing. It takes some training, we had to train people how to submit to one another and reading scripture. But I wish we could do that in regard to sexuality. I wish we could do that, with regard to all the all the problems we have in our towns and villages and families, even over issues of finances. You know, let's listen to Scripture, listen to the gifts of the Holy Spirit, submit to one another and then say, it seems good to us and the Holy Spirit that He is leading us to do this.

Seth 34:05

So I want to push on that a little bit. Because the way that my brain works, I can see…so say, I'm out here in Central Virginia, and the people that I'm involved with whatever the community is, however many hundreds or thousands of us are, I come to a submission to one another that this is the way that scripture is viewed. And then someone and say, I don't know, let's say somewhere in Iowa, I don't even know what town in Iowa, that’s sad, whatever, a town in a different state that they come to the opposing view. So then how did those two sects come together and figure out how to lower the banner, or to use a descriptor that you use, when they don't agree? Like how did those two after they've come to a massive consensus between the two, which is amazing if it happens, because people are letting go of power, which is one of the most Christ like things I think you can do. And it's hard to do. So how do you do it when you know, across our country or across the ocean, the two opposing sides come into clash, like just in the past few years, and you've got, you know, the Methodist Church on homosexuality, but you also have the Methodist Church on women in ministry. And I believe like the Mennonite Church is coming up for a vote on that in the next little bit. And the the covenant was called evangelical covenant church is coming up for it again, and I think they just decided to table it, because nobody could figure out how to talk about it. So what happens for those that do talk about it, you know, they made a decision. And it disagrees with another massive body that has also figured out how to submit one another. And they've made a decision. How do you know he wants us to?

David

in regard to denominational structures? You know, I probably shouldn't try to give a single answer to all the problems that we have, across all denominations. But if I were a denominational President, I would charge all the issues that we cannot agree on, I would give the local churches power to discern this locally and give some freedom in the various churches to discern things locally.

But we will find out where God is working and where he's leading and where he's not. The fruit will become apparent. But I think the real revolution and things that shaped our churches start locally. I think the problem with United Methodist is they tried to enforce a single unilateral decision from the top down across multiple contextual boundaries. I don't even think American white people in the United Methodist Church understood that when the Africans were saying the word sexuality, they did not mean the same thing that Americans mean, when they say sexuality.

I could go off on a riff on that. But the fact is, power structures of denominations trying to enforce a singular decision top down through a vote is a recipe for disaster because it employs worldly power, not the power of the Holy Spirit. I think we need to start locally, give it 10 to 15 years and a consensus…

Host note:

Time out real quick. So you'll notice there and the audio just went crazy. I don't know what happened to the internet. I'm going to blame it on nobody. So what we did is I decided to go old school when him got David's phone number. So I apologize for this brief interruption. Here we go. We'll do the rest. A little bit more old school. Back to it.

David

Dave Fitch here…

Seth

Here we go! We will finish it old school. So yeah, so to recap that, because some of the cut in and out. So basically, where you can agree, give the local church autonomy to make that decision for what works best in the community that they're in?

David

Yeah, yeah. And I wouldn't say autonomy. But I wouldn't call it autonomy, because we're all linked. But what it means is we're giving freedom to open space for those conversations and discernment locally, on the ground. Listen to people, listen to Scripture. If I were denominations, I'd give some, you know, some simple directive, some handouts, some directions, and study scripture together locally. And I do believe, I do believe when there's not consensus, I do believe over time, the fruit will be born and become clear and eventual consensus will happen.

I mean, isn't this the way? You know? I mean, I don't want to idealize or romanticize the great councils of the third and fourth and fifth century because there was actually a lot of Constantinian power being wielded around at Nicea and elsewhere. But you know, basically, things were happening on the ground in various regions of the church. And they came together to discern and ask what's happening over there? What's happening over here? And how does this make sense? And what can we learn from each other in terms of assembling a unifying document? And I think that's what we need to do again.

Seth

So I'm glad that you went there. For those that haven't bought David's book go and do so. Because this entire episode, we've bounced around themes that are in an appendix at the back at least, that's what I'm hearing, David. And if I mishearing that wrong, you just tell me, but most people don't read pass the last chapter. So you have to appendix is dependencies, whatever that word is? And so I'm going to read those out if that's alright, with you.

So you know, the first thing you talk about, you know, for tactics for engagement, you know, we're opening space, for the antagonisms is, tell a story about a real person, and then ask how do we discern this issue, which is what you know, you basically just broke down, make observations and ask questions that reveal the contradictions at work, which I really like, because that forces me to have to listen to you. Like I have here, what you saying? Because I have to ask questions about the contradiction, as opposed to saying… “You're, you're stupid, of course” you read it wrong. I mean, of course, you're from, you know, you're from you from wherever you're from. That's y'all are stupid over there”.

You know, and then, three, don't humiliate or defeat the other person, which is literally what I just did,

David

Laughter.

Seth

Four start in agreement, from what we have in common, and I think that is perfectly fine. What it was somebody I spoke with Bonnie Kristian, that said, you know, concentric circles, like we don't agree about a lot of dogma. But that dogma doesn't matter as much as what we do agree on. And that's Jesus. And so let's focus on that, and then branch out from there. And then lastly, you know, make a proposal in the spirit of mutual submission. And I just love those five things. And I wonder what the church would maybe look like, in the future if we actually did that. And so that leads me to my final question.

You know, I am a millennial. I'm one of the first of the generations of millennials, barely a millennial, but I relate a lot to them. And so people in my age demographic are, like, jettisoning as quickly as possible from the church, because I'm so sick and tired of it, just all of it capital “I” capital “T”, just all of it. Yeah. And so, for pastors listening, how can they use those five things I just very briefly read out to create a place or a new type of church, that will be something that both I and my children will exist in? Because I'm terrified that if I honestly am terrified that whatever version of the American church exists, it won't be that. I don't know what it will be. But I know if it looks like it does now, it will just get more and more unhealthy. So how can we take those five things and create a better, like a better church that millennials are happy to go to? Because to be frank, they are the biggest population in not only this country, most countries.

David

So yeah, yeah. Well, we're in a hell of a mess right now.

You know, for years, especially if you're a white, old guy, old, defined as 50 and over, you grew up in a time when white Christians were pretty much in charge, and even in charge in a way of the culture. And that's all like, flittering away, and those who are out of those time frames, but even those who've been raised by people who were used to that, we want to hold on, and we're used to just arguing and holding on to our power.

And when that's no longer there, we now we're in a space of mission, and we just have to operate totally differently. We can't assume anything, we can't actually assume there's any power to be granted. And so we must become organizers of the Kingdom. The way we organize, is by doing those things, you just like described in the appendix but really that run throughout the whole book. I've written this book to try to help people to understand the dynamics that are work it ideologically that come from, you know, Christendom wanting to hold on to its power, and it's not going to work. And so we have to give up the power. And we have to trust the power at work in Christ, wherever we gather in his name.

And so I'll summarize those tactics you just set off the appendix with the story of Jesus and the adulteress and, you know, in John chapter 8, the adulterous is put into kind of the middle of or before everybody as an object of distain, an enemy. And so often, pastors, churches, get caught up in in that that issue, we have an enemy and by the way, the world just presents us for these terms all the time, because this is the way the world operates. Apart from God, well, we don't want to do that. Nobody is an enemy. Enemies might be revealed, but we don't make enemies. And it's not our job to call out the enemy instead. You know.

So where was I? My son just walked? You said, you said,

Seth

you said enemies might be revealed, but we don't make enemies.

Hey Elmer how are you doing?

David

Laughter—-Don’t call him that…ha ha..he didn’t hear that.

speaks with Son! more laughter

Okay, anyways, let's get back on track here. Yeah, the adulterous is being made into an object of disdain the enemy when must overcome that, by, you know, whenever we're in the middle of these arguments, or tempted to enter into these antagonisms. Tell a real story about a real person or ask the person their story. And when the real facts come out, the issues come out. It's hard to make an enemy out of it person, but instead God wants to work in and through that person.

Jesus, you know, makes observations and starts with agreements, basically says, Okay, yeah, you are perfect. Yeah, I agree with the law. The law has become the theology of banner in this case. When the Pharisees asked Jesus, what shall we do stone her according to the law, and they're trying to turn the law into a banner and Jesus resists that. And he just says, frankly, does something to reveal the contradiction in their lives by finding a point of agreement? And he says something like, yeah, you who are perfect…throw the first stone. And then of course, they're able to see the contradiction. And they all start walking away. And that clear space for Jesus to be present to the adulterous and say you are forgiven. Say you are loved, and now go and work out your salvation go and send them. We the church need to be Jesus in clearing the antagonisms. Allowing them to fritter away because God can't work in in these antagonistic environments. Conflict is one thing, turning them into antagonism is another thing. And we must be present to one another. And the conflicts allow the antagonism to go away, clear space for God to work, reconciliation, and healing in and through Jesus Christ. That's my challenge. That's the call of the church to be this kind of people in our culture today. This is what God wants to do. He will raise up a new people, and millennials and everybody else that so aggravated pissed off and wants to walk away from church will be lining up to become part of this. This new movement of God in our culture, I believe.

Seth

Yeah, I hope so. Point people in the right place, David, where do they go? Where do they either yell at you if they disagree, so that we can find that common ground? Or we're hopefully that's not what happens? Where do they go to interact with you get the book, which I'm sure is available, everywhere that books are available. But where would you point people to?

David

I have a lively conversation that goes on on my Facebook page, David Fitch, Fitchest, at Facebook, you can't become my friend, because I don't have any space. And I won't go to a public page. But followers, just follow me. And you'll get in on all the conversations. I have a Twitter page, which is pretty active, @FITCHEST. And you can buy the book, of course at Amazon, in your local bookstore, or wherever you find books.

Seth

Perfect.

Thank you so much for coming on. And I've enjoyed it quite a bit.

David

Good to be with you, man. And I hope to meet you along the way there in Virginia Keep up the good work,

Seth

Will do

Outro

The appendix at the back there, right that we went over at the tale end it is simplistically hard. And it is something I've tried to model not only in the way that I did faith since reading this book, but in just the way that I do conversations, it is really helped me oftentimes see things from a different lens. And there have been a lot of things that have come into contact of my life lately that have done that have re-framed the way that I see the world. And it is uncomfortable. And I think that it is true. I think that I meet God there. And I think that I'm changing in ways that I wouldn't have thought prior. And so I hope that you got as much out of today's conversation as I did a very special thank you to Derek Meyers for your music for today's episode. You'll find links to all of his stuff in the show notes as well as everything that David and I spoke about. I cannot wait for next week. We're going to have a conversation about Henry now and and that is fantastic. I'm excited for that very excited.

I hope that you realize how beloved you are. Be blessed. Talk to you next week.

Parenting Forward with Cindy Wang Brandt / Transcript

Note: Can I Say This at Church is produced for audio listening. If able, I strongly encourage you to listen to the audio, which has inflection, emotion, sarcasm where applicable, and emphasis for points that may not come across well in written word. This transcript is generated using a combination of my ears and software, and may contain errors. Please check the episode for clarity before quoting in print.


Intro

Hey there, welcome back to the show. This is Seth. And you should know which show you're listening to. I mean you downloaded it. So welcome to the show. I'm glad you downloaded. I'm glad you're here, big things happening. So some great conversations upcoming for the next few weeks and then hopefully for the next few months but I think that should work itself out. Before we get started with a couple brief announcements.

I cannot thank the supporters of the show enough. Patreon supporters y'all have been such a tremendous blessing and so some of the things that I want to try to do for next year I sent this out to the Patreon supporters and if you haven't jumped into that yet, consider doing so you'll find links in the show notes or at the website for the show or a bunch of different ways.

I really want to try to do some form of a live event like a gathering of everybody where we just get together. I don't know what that looks like. And I'm beginning the early stages. And I've gotten some wise counsel from both a friend and one of the supporters of the show on Hey, make sure that we do this with intentionality. And so I think that that will happen and hopefully it will happen sometime early next year, but I'm really excited about the possibility for it and that is really because of people that support the show. So thank you and if you haven't done that yet, consider doing it. Remember to rate and review the show, recently they just continued to uptick and that helps you know as people search for what they want to hear in the podcast things, be it Podbean or Apple iTunes. It lets people know hey, other people are enjoying this and so you may too when they search for God or faith or religion or deconstruction or trauma or doubts or really anything that we talked about here on the show. And so consider doing that because it's literally What's it take like 42 seconds you can do this. Enough of that.

Oh no, not enough of that! Another brief announcement is this store for the show, I am going to try a couple of new things. So if you are a patron supporter of the show, today, most likely you will get an email with a “Hey, if you support the show on Patreon of any level, you're going to get a discount coupon code for things that are on the podcast store at the website”. And I recently added a new shirt there I've tweaked a few things and I have some ideas for a couple other things that I want to do there but that takes time. It's just me. And I only have so much of it but be patient with me there but I'm really enjoying that. It's crazy.

There's there have been mugs that have been shipped to Australia and stuff to Canada and stuff to the like it's it's insane. You people are insane. And I love every single one of you, so thank you.

Today's conversation I thought we’d do something easy maybe to have a conversation on parenting and how to do that well, in this new age that we live in, because this our generation is entirely different than the one that raised us, like, we're just different. Everything about us is different. We are more communal and less communal. At the same time, we have easier access to information. And because of that, we can use that for hate and bigotry. And so I figured we would bring on Cindy Wang Brandt, and talk about parenting like what that looks like going forward. And so I really hope that you enjoy this conversation with Cindy. She's doing some very cool things I would highly recommend. We'll talk about some things at the end of the episode, that you dive into that to the seven or eight of you that recommended Hey, you should really talk with Cindy. I heard you I reached out to her months ago just took some time. But thank you for that recommendation. And so if you're listening and you're like, Hey, I would like to know about this or can you talk with this person? The answer is probably yes. Just tell me who that is. And what piques your interest there and I will figure out how to come at it at the most honest and transparent way that I can so here we go. conversation about parenting because it matters.

Seth

Cindy Wang Brant, welcome to the show. And for those that heard all the stuff prior, you'll realize why you're on the show. But thank you for coming onto the show. Also, most people when I email them are not as succinct as you and I can't tell you how nice it is to not have to go back and forth with 27 different emails to nail down the date. And so I appreciate your brevity and your punctuality which, for those that know me well will know why that matters. But thank you so much because I struggle with calendaring things. So you made it easy and I appreciate that but Welcome to the show.

Cindy

Yeah, well um yeah, I don't really like long rambling emails either so I appreciate your succinct emails that's, that's the strangest thing I've been complimented on but I like it.

Seth

I get yelled at at work because I only type something in the subject line and it's one sentence and there is nothing in the body. But effectively I don't even want you to have an excuse to not know what I said in the email.

Cindy

I wonder if… I worked for a comp like a business company before and I business emails tend to be very just bullet points. I think in like writer communities is much different because we're writers we love words. And I think maybe I have some of that past experiencea that influences things. It was like to waste people's time either.

Seth

It was well definitely not a waste of time, but I it's so much easier. So anyway, that is all beside the point. Welcome to the show. I'm excited to have you here. You're doing big things and from what I understand, based on a moment ago, it's in the morning for you so for those listening where exactly are you?

Cindy

I am in Taiwan. So yes I am exactly 12 hours from eastern time before daylight savings kicks in and then it's like 13 hours which to me makes all the difference 12 and 13 I think the math is a lot easier if it’s just 12 hours

Seth

13 which way forward backwards?

Cindy

Yeah, so it's Friday here already.

Seth

Well, happy almost weekend. So here we go. So for those that are unfamiliar with you, tell us a bit about you. You know, what makes me tick specifically religiously, but overall just kind of how are you you like what are those things in life that you know when I think back? This is why I am what I am today. Yeah. So specifically religiously?

Cindy

I grew up conservative evangelical, and I have since deconstructed which is a term I know a lot of people use, but not everyone loves it. But that's the process. I would say my 30s, I'm 41 now. So it's been a long journey. So I now am more of an Ex-Vangelcial. For the past few years, I published a book called parenting forward and I've been kind of moderating a Facebook group called raising children unfundamentalist and the spirit of my work is, I feel like it's kind of the next step in my deconstruction is figuring out how to parent the next generation and not just parent but teachers and educators and Sunday school ministers. How do we shepherd the next generation of kids and values that matter to us? How to shed the toxicity that a lot of us have wrestled with? So that's the work that I do right now; so I'm a writer, podcaster, speaker. And but yeah, most of my work is with this niche of parenting and progressive faith.

Seth

So how has that been? Because that was like, so 10 years ago, and you and then I don't know when you started deconstructing. But let's say 10 years ago, because why not?

Cindy

Yeah

Seth

Is that what you thought you would be doing now? Like, did you like, how did it How did you? How did you not set segues, not the word How did you migrate? That's a better word, migrate to that lane.

Cindy

I think because of my own life experience, I started to I think part of becoming a writer was part of my deconstruction because you know what, I don't I don't know if you grew up conservative evangelical, but in this fundamentalist mindset, we were not encouraged to really pursue our passions and interests it was all about God how we can serve God best and, and yeah, there were like, you these little quizzes on your spiritual gifts and stuff. But as a whole, like, part of deconstructing for me was very much recovering my gifts and my calling and so that was becoming a writer was part of that but when I started writing, you know, when you start writing you, it takes a while to discover your voice. So I was writing different things just to test things out and, and eventually I landed on writing about faith. I think because it was just the most important thing to me, was the truest part of my experience. And so I started writing faith and then I you know, kind of in the in the footsteps of like Rachel Held Evans and Sarah Bessy and, and all these bloggers who were walking this path of evolving faith, and then I was raising kids. I been raised the evangelical I got married young and had kids young and so my kids were quickly growing up as I was going through this process of deconstructing.

So I realized that there was this clash intention of, well then how do I raise my kids when I'm going through all this anger and anxiety and not one wanting to pass on kind of my spiritual trauma and giving them values to live by or a faith or lack thereof? And I don't have any answers. But like so many other writers, I think we write as we learn, right? So I wanted to learn I wanted to gather a community of people who felt the same way so that we could pull our resources and our ideas and say, Well, how do we do this? You know, I have this problem. How do we deal with this? So that's how I landed on it. And then it turned into started as a blog series back when people did blog series and turned into a book and the book and the Facebook group and, and now I'm running a conference.

Seth

So yeah, I saw that. So that that looks that looks fun that Well, I I say fun. It would drive me insane. Like I, I struggle if I don't have control of all I think is we've I think if we've we've found out if I don't have control the pieces that's just I'm going to see in a self psychoanalyze there. So real question, I thought we'd start with an easy question about parenting. So A: I am a kid and many I am a kid, I have kids, and many that have listened to the show since the beginning. What broke open my faith into a deconstruction, will use the same term there, was having kids because there are parts of me that I see in them that I don't always see in me. And I find I often see healthy and unhealthy parts of both myself. And in the way that I see God changes as I watch my kids grow, if that makes sense.

Cindy

Yeah. Very common story.

Seth

Yeah, um, well, that's good, I guess. Well, I hope. I hope it's a good story.

Anyway, so what I thought I'd start with an easy question, what is what should our job be as parents?

Cindy

I think growing up in an authoritarian system, or at least authoritarian religion, one of the most damaging things was the way it wrested control out of children, I think the most important thing we can do is offer our children autonomy. So I think the job of us as parents, is to figure out how we can give our children as much of their autonomy as we can, even as we are responsible for taking care of them. And so that I think is our most important job, how do we kind of guard our children's time? And I think a lot of times we say giving our children autonomy, it seems like…”Oh, so we just kind of let them do whatever they want”. But it's also understanding that there are forces in this world and then the system who seek to undermine their autonomy, and protecting them from that as well.

So I think about like the market fundamentalism is real, you know, all those ads, all these messages, trying to tell our kids to buy, buy, buy to the status that's kind of robbing them of their autonomy. There's, it's a billion dollar industry to, you know, create messaging that manipulates our children's brains. I think about messaging that tells our girls that they have to be a certain size or that they have to be small, that they have to be quiet. That's also something that robs our girls have their autonomy. And so I think our job as parents is to figure out what are the things that take away their their freedom, and offer it to them so that they could kind of cultivate their true-selves in the environment of our families.

Seth

I wanted to touch on a few things there. So when I hear autonomy, what I think of is, do your own thing and don't hurt anybody. Don't hurt yourself and don't hurt anyone else. And so when you say autonomy, what do you mean? Like, what does that look like on a Tuesday or on a Friday like… so my son's 10. So what does an autonomy? What does autonomy mean for a 10 year old?

Cindy

Yeah, no, I think for a 10 year old, it looks like first for them to develop what they like and what they don't like. The way that what they choose to do with their free time, what they choose to eat, what they choose to wear, those are the things that develop the sense that they can trust themselves and then they can discover who they are without intervention from, you know, outside influences. And if you want to dig a little deeper into like, you know, gender identity and all these things know we're discovering how harmful it is for let's say trans kids to be told they're certain gender when they feel differently inside.

So those those are the things but also I think, for a 10 year old autonomy means, how do they get to be a creative, create creatively express who they are in this world? Because I believe we're all creatives, just by being—just by existing, were having some sort of impact in this world. And so how does a 10 year old present themselves? Do they have access to ways that they can be who they are, project who they are? So, you know, for some people, it might be, whatever YouTube channel lots of kids are doing that or be you know, participating in the community theater or playing a sport, whatever it is, do they have access to those things to live out who they are.

Seth

I want to I want to stay on the community and autonomy. So if I agree, and I wrestle with this often because I as working as a banker, I know that I perpetuate this society of “hoard wealth”, more like it's always “How can I help you? Cindy, how can I make sure that you're set up? Well, when you're 60, 50, 80, 90 127, however old, which there's an inherent selfishness with that, and so if I'm trying to, I mean, I just literally talked about this with my daughter before bedtime, who's literally right above us. I'm all above me. She's not above you, anyway, of you know, you have too many things and she's constantly asking for so many more things. And some of that is her friends. We don't have cable so we pretty much watch Netflix like we we don't see any ads for anything.

Cindy

Yeah,

Seth

but there's something there. And just the way that at least, I don't know how Taiwan is, is Taiwan similar in that sense in the way that Americans…

Cindy

Yeah…capitalism is kind of everywhere. Yeah.

Seth 18:03

How do we model as parents that what we have is enough? Does that make because I feel oftentimes, you know, my wife and I are very similar, you know, in similar in making the same mistakes of this is a good sale. I can't afford not to buy that, like,

Cindy

yeah,

Seth

how do you effectively model? What is enough? Because the fear is it five years from now, man eight years from now, you know, she starts driving and I built a bubble around her and then she doesn't know how to cope in the world that does exist because I don't think capitalism is going away anytime soon. And I want to make sure that she's healthfully prepared to engage in society. When she is more autonomous than my roof.

Cindy

Yeah. Well, let me flip the question around a little bit instead of saying, how do we kind of instead of going on the defense against capitalism, let's go on offense. When will we can show our kids that life that there's a lot of life outside of just, you know, the material things. So I'm thinking, getting out in nature, showing them how wonderful and life giving nature could be showing them how kind of scaling down your life can bring you so much joy. And that could be really simple just like spending an evening, you know, playing games that, you know, 10 year old games that you have sitting on your shelf, because I don't we never want to like rules, like rules is very against kind of what what I'm about, right? We don't want to say don't buy this, don't buy that. But to give the alternative, like look at the profound joy that can come from simplicity from being grounded in the outside world. So yeah, I don't know if that's helpful to kind of go on the offense…

Seth

It is helpful, and we do that. So I live at the base of the Blue Ridge Mountains. We were out just last week my wife, myself, and my son went on a 14 mile bike ride.

Cindy

Yeah, so that's free, right?

Seth

too which he hated every minute of it because, you know, it's hot. And I'm like, well, you just be quiet. There's no cell phone service out here. How cool is this? There's literally no service out here.

Cindy

Yeah. And letting the kids be bored. Like I think boredom is a really huge thing.

I know it's hard but just to be still and to practice I'm, it's hard for me to think it's hard for all of us because we're all kind of intertwined in the system. But I think it's so important. And, and also, like, I think for a lot of us, like I got into this whole parenting forward thing because I realized that there was a crisis. A lot of times we only make changes when there's a crisis. And I had a crisis of faith shift.

So I think with like capitalism, you know, I think reveal to you to, you know, maybe you and your partner and your children that we were in a crisis here, we're in a crisis where we're overwhelmed with too much stimulation, too much stuff.

Talk about climate change. This is a crisis. Too much stuff is killing the earth. Too much carbon, whatever usage. We have a crisis we need to figure out ways to combat it.

Seth

You write in your book about justice and dignity, and I want to center in on dignity because I've never really heard anyone I never read anyone either. Before what I read in your book about dignity and like you talk about I've heard you talk other well other other places as well about like the United Nations in the way that we as a society, in a culture, dignify kids, and kids is probably a bad word for that. Can you talk to that a bit because I honestly I'd never heard nor read nor even really thought about any of that?

Cindy

Right, I think it's a blind spot a lot of us still have because for years and years and years, but most of human history, children are treated as subhuman. It's only until the last few decades that the United Nations has even recognize that a child is a human being. So it's very recent that we're starting to politically and legally treat children as human beings. But culture, I think popular culture, is still even now taking time to catch up to that standard. And so in many ways, we do treat children as subhuman. And it's easy to do that because they're vulnerable and they can't speak up for themselves. So you know, one example is just posting pictures of kids, we everyone post pictures of their of their babies because babies give consent. And so there's something to it. And I'm not saying that it's across the board, bad to post pictures of babies, but it's something that we just don't even think about.

We take for granted that we can do this without their consent. And that's kind of not treating them as a human being because with other human, you usually ask for consent. Once you open your eyes to that blind spot, then you kind of see it everywhere. You realize the many ways the way people talk about children. There's so many, like parenting humor, websites and videos, it's all over. And some of them are good, but some of them are seriously anti-child. And so I would love for us to kind of wake ourselves up to this reality. And, yeah, talk about how can we actually treat children as human beings?

Seth

So I'll ask you for some of those examples. So outside of not posting them on Instagram or Facebook or Twitter without consent, because I think you're right. I my wife and I've argued about this before of, you know, when, when our kids in 10 years from now, like everything that's on the internet is not going away and we've built this persona of only their best moments, or their most embarrassing moments, one or the other.

Cindy

Right

Seth

And that's who they are, like, that's who the internet. And the algorithms think that that's what they are. Which will impact the news that they see the jobs that they get the college that they get into, it will impact a lot of things. But besides that, what are some other examples to I guess, humanify…that's not a word

Cindy

Humanize.

Seth

There it is. That's the one. Children like, what are some other things for those listening? And they're like, Oh, I didn't see that. It's like just that in the family level. Like, what are some things to do?

Cindy 24:41

Yeah, I think when it comes to like media, when you hear people talk about children or post a video of children or anything in popular media, picture yourself, viewing that from the perspective of a child and think to yourself, what would a child think about this? How would a child feel? I think that's a really effective way. That's what I do to try to kind of get a different perspective.

When it comes to the family, there's gosh, there's so many things like one example that I can think of is, a lot of times our children have emotions. And guess what emotions are super, super human like that.

Seth

and by “alot of times” you mean “All the time”

Cindy

Yeah. I mean, it's like, they get frustrated, they complain, they get angry, they get sad, they get distressed, they get happy there's all this range of emotions that we seem to allow adults to have and just say, yeah, that's totally understandable. And yet when it comes to children, we rush to comfort them to say stop being sad, stop being angry, stop being all these things. And it just is a total double standard. We seem to not let kids be human just as much as we are. And so I think, again, when we have these encounters with our children just think well, how would I want…It's the golden rule…How would I want to be treated if I have been tired and hot all day and I complain really loudly about something. How would I want to be treated?

Seth 26:34

I do want to pivot to that. So I feel like churches in specific, and I did you'd asked earlier you didn't know my upbringing. So I did grow up relatively Southern Baptist-ish. I grew up in the central part of Texas. And part of me doesn't like that. And the other part of me understands that because of that, I'm still the person that I am today. Like, there's still some value in all of that.

Cindy

Yeah,

Seth

here's not and not everything was bad. I won't ever say that. There were some things that were very unhealthy. And so for those that are influencing the children that are in our faith communities, how do they better do that outside of just once a year? Because my fear is and this is often when your name has been recommended is my fear is 30 years from now the church that exists is a broken one, because we haven't been intentional with focusing on I don't want to say youth, I want to say the next generation that will come after us. So what are some ways that we can humanize, enlighten, glorify and and allow space for questioning in our churches? Because the answer would change from denomination to denomination but there has to be a few basic tenants. I think that would work well. Any at any intersection of faith?

Cindy

Well, a lot of people ask me about how to, because I talk a lot I'm their social justice, I talk alot about advocating for marginalized people. And kind of like diversity and reconciliation, those are all kind of buzzwords in faith communities, like we want to be multicultural and, and all these things. And a lot of times people will say, well, we welcome them into our pews. But what we really should be saying is how do we welcome them into our leadership and allow them to have a say in how things are actually run at the most influential levels?

Now, this is tricky to do with children, because are you really going to have children step into board meetings? And my answer is, why not? You know? So I think I think we have to listen to the people. So I feel like I keep repeating myself. It's like think about what a child would say think; same thing when it comes to faith communities how does your child feel? How would a child feel if they stepped into church for the first time? How would they be treated? How would they want the church to be run?

Seth

Do you think we've gotten better? Since you've been studying this? Like as you've as you've watched you year after year after year? Do you feel like we're getting any better as I don't want to say a civilization because every country is different. But do you feel like we're progressing at all? Or are we just stagnant?

Cindy

Since I've been doing this so long? I mean, three or four years?

Seth

Since you since you've been watching?

Cindy

No, I don’t.

Seth

Well, that's awful.

Cindy

Yeah, well, but it hasn't, you know, in the grand scheme, if you think about the history of human civilization, and that's it's only been a couple few decades that you're not even so in the grand scheme of things three and four years is a drop in the bucket, so I wouldn't be too discouraged. I think that the work of justice for children is a marathon.

And that anything that is worth, that is actual change and meaningful change takes a long time. So I wouldn't be too discouraged. I think we just have to stick with it for the long haul. The reason that I say no is because the fundamentalist influence continues to be there. Authoritarianism is continuing to be a huge influence that permeates not just faith communities, but culture. I see that and I realize that we have a long way to go. Are there more resources being created and communities that are trying to truly honor children happening?

I think what I can tell you that I'm discovering more of them, but a lot of them don't get airtime. They just don't get the publicity, which is frustrating to me and something I'm really trying to change. So with this Parenting Forward Conference, it's like I've gathered all these people who are doing amazing work, trying to honor children's autonomy and but you know, many of them don't have big platforms.

So I just want to do my best to keep spreading this message and saying there are Coalition's of people who are doing this work, let's join them and amplify their voices and make our voice louder than the fundamentalists.

Seth

I want to ask you things that I'm sure you've been asked before, and I'll try to do it in the best way possible. But really, they're going to be either questions directly from listeners, because I sequestered questions, I have created this very small community at stay small intentionally and I said, “Hey, I'm gonna be talking about parenting. What do you want to know”? And so I'm going to pull some of those up. I'll be honest, though, that a lot of them center on sexuality, LGBTQ and that type of stuff and so I want to ask you a few of those if that's okay.

Cindy

Sure.

Seth

One person said, and I'll just quote them here. So it says, I know that if asked directly by my son, that my parents will tell him that they believe that his lesbian moms are sinning by even being together and that they believe that we will go to hell for it. When this comes up, how should I address this?

Cindy

When the kids say that… just say grandma's wrong? So, so easy.

Seth

Is it though?

Cindy

It's so funny, because when you told me you solicited questions from your group I was like, I bet I can anticipate every single one of them. A very, very common question is how to deal with fundamentalist parents grandparents.

Seth

Well, that's one of my questions. And specifically, it would be not grandparents, it would be my parent,

Cindy

but your kids grandparents, right?

Seth

Yes.

Cindy

There is so much tension, I think that this is quite particular to our generation right now, because of the changes that have been happening in faith demographics. I think that historians, religious historians, are going to look back at this time and say that this is kind of when we started splitting.

So this is a very common problem. It's very hard for me to give answers because every family is so different and everyone has different values and priorities. I personally would not hesitate to tell my kids that grandma's wrong about this because if anything our kids are more gay affirming than we are. For them they're growing up watching LGBTQ characters in Marvel movies… well, not Marvel quite yet, but it's coming the pipeline.

Seth

Really?

Cindy

Yes, yeah, they have some.

Seth

I don't keep up with it. I just watched the movies, I don't really read about any of the other things. I do enjoy watching them.

Cindy

But you know, TV shows, books, there are lots of for many of them, it's really a non-issue, I don't know if we need to…

Seth

then let me pivot that question, then how do I feel like what I'm hearing in that question is how do I deal as a parent and I'm not, I'm definitely not a lesbian. So how do I deal as a parent with possible shame that comes from that conversation?

Cindy

Yeah.

Seth

How do I help?

Cindy

Yeah, I think it's really important to first of all, recognize that it's shame in this really quite abusive, right for our parents to say that you're living in sin and that who you are. That's, that's abuse. And I think we have to call it what it is, in order to know how to deal with it. And if you know that someone has been abusive to you, you have to create some distance draw some very solid boundaries.

And, as well for your children and say that well, I'm going to choose to not expose my children to that kind of rhetoric. I know it's hard because they’re grandparents and you want them also have that love and nurturing. But so as much as possible, like if it's possible, to still give them exposure but have certain boundaries. But for some families, it's just not possible, especially with very conservative family members, they don't respect those boundaries. And in that case, you know, you still hold the power to how much time you spend with your grandparents, how often you speak to them. And that's the thing about the autonomy to you have the power and I think it's really important to give our kids the power to say that you can express your opinions in front of authority, right, like that's, to me, that's very important that they should never be afraid to say, you know, to say what they believe or or assert themselves.

Seth

So that leads me to my next question. So the age that you and I live in now the the social media age would be the it's…in everything is politically charged. Right. And I've often thought I mean, school just started on Tuesday, and I've already had both of my kids that go to school. Talking about the President and the teacher said this or that said that.

And I am quick to tell them you know, that's wrong, that's racist, and it doesn't matter what anybody says or that's what is loving is loving. And if that offends people, that's more about them, than anything else,

Cindy

Right.

Seth

But how would you recommend someone parents in a way that they I mean, you have to talk about politics because if you don't, that’s think that's dangerous to such as to shy away from the conversation on the other. So how do you broach that topic either, but with children of any age, but But mostly, you know, in a healthy and intentional way?

Cindy

I think there's two things. First of all, I think as parents, we've kind of earned the right to tell our children our values. So let's say you're affiliated with a certain political party, like I think it's okay to tell your child Okay, I'm, you know, whatever. I'm this political party, because these values I align with this is what I believe in. And for now, I think it's important to add for now, because we can always change this is what I align with, and but the other piece of parenting is to give your children again, that autonomy to explore and make decisions for themselves.

And more likely than not, they will imitate you, I found that that's just true, and that's just what children do. But as much as possible, and especially as they grow and as they develop more mature cognitive and critical thinking capacities, the more they can desent and discuss and debate. And I think those are all really good skills and what better way for them to do that, but to practice with you and the safety of your home, but I do agree with you that it's so important now for the kids to learn how to live with a plurality of people with different convictions and how to engage and how to live in society. Like that's those are just life skills, right.

But yeah, so I would say first, don't be afraid. I think a lot of progressive parents are kind of afraid to assert their own ideas and opinions because they're so concerned about letting their kids decide for themselves. I think it's okay, we're all humans and we all get to it's our right to have an opinion. So we share our opinions, but we also give them the space to develop their own.

Seth

At least, and again, I don't know the demographics of where you're at, but within the next, you know, decade or so, at least in the area that I live, my children will become the minority. And so I try to intentionally prepare them for what that should look like. Yeah, always trying to reframe that lens. But I don't know that everybody is intentional that way. And so what are some resources? I mean, you've alluded to this conference and I do want to plug that at the end. I've listened to the most recent episode of your podcast, and I heard about that, and I thought that's, that's a good thing. I also like the time frame that you're doing it in because I work for a living and so that's fantastic. But we will get there in a minute.

What are some resources to do that in an interfaith way? Because it can't just be Christianity that has that conversation. And it can't just be Islam that has that conversation or Hindu or Buddhist or Sikh. So are there any resources to bring faith communities together, to do this as a village is really a tripe word is the wrong way to say it, but it's the best way I can come up with.

Cindy

Okay. Well, you talked, you touched on two things you touched on on race and religion. So I didn't know which one you want me to address.

Seth

I mean, well, they're going to blend together but mostly I want to know where their conversations or communities or resources that blend the faith together. So interfaith because there's truth that you can learn from, there's a lot of truth to learn from other faiths if you can get outside of the Bible Belt.

Cindy

Today, I was just helping promote a curriculum called A Joyful Path, which is an interfaith spiritual curriculum. And I actually got a coupon code it’s CWB 25 and you get 25% off the curriculum there and I'll give you the link that you can link to your show notes. Yes, so that's a spiritual curriculum that is interfaith. It's probably more Christians still drawing mostly on Bible stories, but they have some folk tales from other cultures and religions. And so kind of that idea that yes, wisdom can be found anywhere. I also had interviewed on my podcast, Susan Katz Miller, who talks about interfaith parenting, how to parent when both parents are of different faiths. So, that's another resource. But, you know, I say we create our own let's get, you know, let's use our imagination, get creative and figure out how to form these communities that are truly diverse, faith wise, and racially, and yeah, if any of your listeners are doing this, like let me know I would love to hear stories of how people are actually doing this in their communities, forming kind of healthy communities. Forming kind of healthy communities that are diverse. I think that we're still figuring that out. Right. And I think that's scary and exciting at the same time.

Seth

I think it's more exciting and scary. Because it means that there's a recognition that the issue exists, which is better than say 15 years ago because you can't fix something if you don't even see it. If that makes sense.

Cindy

I think scary and that people are afraid of offending, you know, with all this talk of cultural appropriation and like being racially insensitive. I think I feel it like I'm afraid to offend someone of another religion or appropriating so but I think we just have to be brave and not be afraid to make some mistakes and to own our mistakes when we do make them. I guess I mean, fear in that way, like, okay, it's gonna be kind of messy.

Seth

Well, anything worth doing is probably slightly messy. So here's my other question that came back to me. So you talked about, you know, children modeling after hopefully healthy parenting. And then I can envision, you know, a 13 year old coming into their own embolden with hormones and everything else that happens, and they're trying to be and I'll use a bad word but you know, some version of their parent as a social, like someone who's going to speak out against oppression, or someone that's going to speak out for justice, or speak out against patriarchy, which is a much bigger topic that we haven't touched on, although it's one that I struggle with how to model what a healthy patriarchy is for my wives or so…for my wives for my daughter so that when they are wives

Cindy

Freudian slip,

Seth

like they know what that looks like, yeah, I hope not. So how, how would you best prepare a child that is in that stage of life, that is trying to do trying to voice their voice and that's the best way that I can say it, but they don't necessarily have the knowledge to back it up. Does that make sense? Because that can that could possibly cause trauma.

Cindy

I think it's I think we let them just like I was saying before, don't be afraid to make mistakes. So don't be afraid to let our children make mistakes. That's how we learn is by making mistakes. So yeah, they're not gonna, you know, they might parent some rhetoric, they might be a little bit offensive, but especially for girls like, because our girls are given such strong messaging from the world then you might not see it because you're a man.

But I think women will be able to tell you…Yeah, we are told to be quiet. We were told to be silent. We're told to not, not speak our opinion out loud. We're told to apologize if our tone isn't quite right. To smile more, to be more polite to be more of a bridge builder. Those are all messaging I receive every single day as a public person as a woman.

So I know that it's out there and I know it's very strong. So anytime girls speak up, have an opinion, share their opinion, however loud they do I say, encourage it, because anything you say to try to tamper that is another voice telling them to be quiet. Like, we have to counter that voice telling them to be quiet, so and but I mean of course what once they, you know speak their opinions and maybe it's like problematic; what they've said. Of course you can have conversations with them and say, Okay, well let's talk about it, but talk to them as equals. Don't condescend. Don't say you said that wrong. That was dumb. You know, don't say that ever again. loud. Say Hey, listen, this is ,you know, this is what I've learned maybe this is something we can discuss. Here's what I feel about it. What do you think.

Seth

Hmm, I promise I'll stop asking questions. So we're beginning to get to questions I have. So for myself, I wasn't raised that way. And I don't think you were either, but I could be wrong with that.

Cindy

Yeah

Seth

I find myself often immediately reverting back to an authoritarian figure. Yeah, I talked about this a few weeks ago with some friends. I don't know if I've ever actually said it out loud. And so I won't edit this out. Maybe I did. I don't remember. I probably have blocked it is traumatic. What are some steps that parents can do when they're starting to realize “holy crap? This is not this is to get unhealthy. Yeah, really quick, right?” Because I often find myself and luckily I married a woman that will come in and be like, you need to Yeah, like I hear your voice. I've known you for a long time. I'm gonna need you to go do literally anything else,

Cindy

Time out for dad.

Seth

But sometimes it's also the same for her like I'll walk Kelly, what do you what are you doing? No, no leave. I need you to go away.

But outside of that, because there's also single parent, a lot of single parents like, what are some what are some practical steps to be like, you know, I feel myself slipping into what was beaten into me quite literally as a child.

Cindy

Yeah, that's a great question. I think this is this is a part of parenting because it allows us and it almost forces us to confront our own wounds. Because if we don't address our own wounds, spiritual or otherwise, and sometimes even physical, then we will risk passing that on just as you describe, will we will use the same system that was used on us will inflict the same pain that we endured on to our children. And so this is almost kind of a separate work apart from your children because your children are not responsible for fixing you or healing you. You have to do that hopefully with other adults or with a therapist. And I think the first thing to do is to actually know, understand that what was done to you was wrong, that it was authoritarian that it was abusive and that you are suffering from trauma. Like you said, all those words, but to reiterate that understand this happened to me it was traumatic. And we know so much more about the way trauma works now that we have the tools and the resources to begin to address it. And none of us are going to do this perfectly, because again, that's not how trauma works. It doesn't just disappear overnight. But I think having the posture of being willing to do the work of healing within ourselves and wanting to do better, is a huge departure from you know, maybe our parents to even that awareness and consciousness. So, yeah, I think one thing I would say is just to be be aware, don't make your children do that work for you. You know, do that work yourselves or with other adults, with your friends, with your community with a therapist.

And I think that will go a long ways to you. And then as you begin to break those cycles of treating your parents differently, I think that is incredibly healing to you, as the parents, as you see, oh, wow, it doesn't have to be this way it gets to stop with me. Like that's incredibly empowering to know that the trauma that happened to us, doesn't control us. It doesn't have to dictate our future and it gets to stop. And I think that will go a long way in even future incidents as you get triggered again, from your own pain to say, Hey, you know, I am resilient, and I can break the cycle.

Seth

I like that. That's a good word. Your kids are not responsible for fixing you. I like that a lot. Plug the places and the so where did the people go? To get your book? Where do they go to get in touch with you and then talk to me a bit about this conference, specifically. And I may edit this part out. When is it? Because I want to make sure the episode is out before that, yeah. so that people can actually participate in the conference, provided it's not like tomorrow because as we've alluded to, I'm the only one that does this. So that's just won't happen.

Cindy

Yeah, so my my conference is called Parenting Forward conference. And you can find the information on that on parentingforwardconference.com, it's going to be online, which means anybody with a computer and an internet connection can join. And it's the dates are September 23 to 27th. And it's going to be every evening and Eastern time. And the reason it's kind of an odd time is because I'm in Taiwan, so I kind of had to fit my schedule. But the good news is that all of the recordings will be accessible to you. So if you can't make it live, then you can just watch the recordings at some other time.

It will be 20 plus speakers all from either parenting niche or the progressive faith niche. And I'm really excited because there are a lot of people who talk about progressive faith. A lot of them are your previous podcast guests. And they don't normally talk about parenting. And this is something that I want to change, because I think parenting is one of the most important things that you can talk about if you want to promote social change. So I'm excited to kind of draw these speakers together to talk about this one topic of how we raise children with justice. And so check out the speakers on the websites. Do you want to get my book it's called parenting forward and it's available on Amazon and everywhere where books are sold.

Seth

So you should go get you should go get the book, I think everyone listening should

Cindy

thank you.

Seth

Thank you so much for coming on. I did not know that there was a 12 hour time difference, but that's even more impressive, but thank you. I really appreciate you coming on.

Cindy

Thank you for having me.

Outro

I like what Cindy said there at the end it is not the work of our children to do the work for us when we go through trauma and I know so many times and I've seen so many people read and write about and speak on you know we have to be the ones that break the cycle and so that can be traumatic cycle that can be abusive cycles that can be sexual abuse that can be bad faith, bad religion and bad ways to binarily see the world I pray and I hope that we just get better at it. I think that we can.

A huge thank you to the Eagle and Child for the use of their music in this show. They have become one of my favorite albums of the year. You will find the music from today on the Spotify playlist for Can I say this at church which because, of some beautiful human, that has been converted into also an apple music playlist. So search for that out and not quite certain how to find that link but feel like if you use Apple Music; you are so I will talk with you all next week. I cannot wait. Have a good one.